CALL OR TEXT US: +1 (619) 714-3800

Boring Plastic Poly Mailers or Custom Compostable Mailers?

Table of Contents

This or That?
Plastic Poly Mailers vs. Custom Compostable Mailers

In a world where sustainability is increasingly top of mind, every purchasing decision counts. When it comes to packaging, the choice between traditional plastic poly mailers and custom compostable alternatives can have a significant impact on the environment and your brand reputation. Let’s explore the pros and cons of each option and help you make an informed decision that aligns with your values and goals.

The Dilemma: Plastic Poly Mailers vs. Compostable Alternatives

On one side, we have plastic poly mailers—a familiar, cheap, and often convenient choice for businesses looking to ship their products. On the other side, we have compostable mailers—an eco-friendly alternative designed to break down naturally over time, leaving behind no harmful residues or pollutants.

The question is: which option will resonate more with your audience and leave a lasting impression?

Breaking Down the Benefits:
Time to Decompose and Environmental Impact

One key factor to consider when comparing plastic poly mailers to compostable alternatives is the time it takes for each material to break down. While plastic poly mailers can persist in the environment for hundreds of years, compostable mailers typically decompose within a matter of months, minimizing their environmental impact and reducing waste accumulation.

What packaging do you want for your brand?

Compostable Mailers Take the Lead

When it comes to sustainability, compostable mailers offer a clear advantage over their plastic counterparts. Made from renewable materials and designed to biodegrade within a specific timeframe, these custom packaging solutions demonstrate a commitment to environmental stewardship and brand awareness. By choosing compostable mailers, businesses can impress customers add more value to their product.

Now you may ask, is sustainable packaging more expensive?

Check out our blog post here debunking the myth with practical insights for businesses.

Considerations for Consumer Preference and Brand Reputation

In today’s market, consumer preferences are shifting toward sustainable and eco-friendly products. By offering custom compostable mailers, businesses can cater to this growing demand and attract environmentally conscious customers. Moreover, choosing compostable packaging can lead to repeat purchases and foster brand loyalty, as consumers are more likely to support brands that align with their values and beliefs.

Explore 10 ways that sustainable packaging impacts brand success in this article by agility PR solutions.

Ready to impress your customers with custom compostable mailers and enhance your brand reputation?
Contact us today to explore sustainable packaging options that align with your values and goals.


The choice between plastic poly mailers and custom compostable alternatives extends beyond functionality—it’s a reflection of your values and commitment to sustainability. By opting for compostable mailers, businesses can not only reduce their environmental footprint but also engage customers, build brand awareness, and foster long-term loyalty.

Make the switch today and join the movement toward a greener, more sustainable future.

To empower individuals & businesses with sustainable solutions for a better future.